A light wind was riffling the waters of the pool below,

Doubt and Doubttwo2023-12-07 11:42:22 24 2875

"I am not hazarding at present any hypothesis as to the probable rate of change, but none will deny that when the annual birth and the annual death of one species on the globe is proposed as a mere speculation, this, at least, is to imagine no slight degree of instability in the animate creation. If we divide the surface of the earth into twenty regions of equal area, one of these might comprehend a space of land and water about equal in dimensions to Europe, and might contain a twentieth part of the million of species which may be assumed to exist in the animal kingdom. In this region one species only could, according to the rate of mortality before assumed, perish in twenty years, or only five out of fifty thousand in the course of a century. But as a considerable portion of the whole world belongs to the aquatic classes, with which we have a very imperfect acquaintance, we must exclude them from our consideration, and, if they constitute half of the entire number, then one species only might be lost in forty years among the terrestrial tribes. Now the mammalia, whether terrestrial or aquatic, bear so small a proportion to other classes of animals, forming less, perhaps, than a thousandth part of a whole, that, if the longevity of species in the different orders were equal, a vast period must elapse before it would come to the turn of this conspicuous class to lose one of their number. If one species only of the whole animal kingdom died out in forty years, no more than one mammifer might disappear in forty thousand years, in a region of the dimensions of Europe.

A light wind was riffling the waters of the pool below,

"It is easy, therefore, to see that in a small portion of such an area, in countries, for example, of the size of England and France, periods of much greater duration must elapse before it would be possible to authenticate the first appearance of one of the larger plants or animals, assuming the annual birth and death of one species to be the rate of vicissitude in the animal creation throughout the world."[3]

A light wind was riffling the waters of the pool below,

In a word, then, said Lyell, it becomes clear that the numberless species that have been exterminated in the past have died out one by one, just as individuals of a species die, not in vast shoals; if whole populations have passed away, it has been not by instantaneous extermination, but by the elimination of a species now here, now there, much as one generation succeeds another in the life history of any single species. The causes which have brought about such gradual exterminations, and in the long lapse of ages have resulted in rotations of population, are the same natural causes that are still in operation. Species have died out in the past as they are dying out in the present, under influence of changed surroundings, such as altered climate, or the migration into their territory of more masterful species. Past and present causes are one--natural law is changeless and eternal.

A light wind was riffling the waters of the pool below,

Such was the essence of the Huttonian doctrine, which Lyell adopted and extended, and with which his name will always be associated. Largely through his efforts, though of course not without the aid of many other workers after a time, this idea--the doctrine of uniformitarianism, it came to be called--became the accepted dogma of the geologic world not long after the middle of the nineteenth century. The catastrophists, after clinging madly to their phantom for a generation, at last capitulated without terms: the old heresy became the new orthodoxy, and the way was paved for a fresh controversy.

The fresh controversy followed quite as a matter of course. For the idea of catastrophism had not concerned the destruction of species merely, but their introduction as well. If whole faunas had been extirpated suddenly, new faunas had presumably been introduced with equal suddenness by special creation; but if species die out gradually, the introduction of new species may be presumed to be correspondingly gradual. Then may not the new species of a later geological epoch be the modified lineal descendants of the extinct population of an earlier epoch?

The idea that such might be the case was not new. It had been suggested when fossils first began to attract conspicuous attention; and such sagacious thinkers as Buffon and Kant and Goethe and Erasmus Darwin had been disposed to accept it in the closing days of the eighteenth century. Then, in 1809, it had been contended for by one of the early workers in systematic paleontology--Jean Baptiste Lamarck, who had studied the fossil shells about Paris while Cuvier studied the vertebrates, and who had been led by these studies to conclude that there had been not merely a rotation but a progression of life on the globe. He found the fossil shells--the fossils of invertebrates, as he himself had christened them--in deeper strata than Cuvier's vertebrates; and he believed that there had been long ages when no higher forms than these were in existence, and that in successive ages fishes, and then reptiles, had been the highest of animate creatures, before mammals, including man, appeared. Looking beyond the pale of his bare facts, as genius sometimes will, he had insisted that these progressive populations had developed one from another, under influence of changed surroundings, in unbroken series.

Of course such a thought as this was hopelessly misplaced in a generation that doubted the existence of extinct species, and hardly less so in the generation that accepted catastrophism; but it had been kept alive by here and there an advocate like Geoffrey Saint-Hilaire, and now the banishment of catastrophism opened the way for its more respectful consideration. Respectful consideration was given it by Lyell in each recurring edition of his Principles, but such consideration led to its unqualified rejection. In its place Lyell put forward a modified hypothesis of special creation. He assumed that from time to time, as the extirpation of a species had left room, so to speak, for a new species, such new species had been created de novo; and he supposed that such intermittent, spasmodic impulses of creation manifest themselves nowadays quite as frequently as at any time in the past. He did not say in so many words that no one need be surprised to-day were he to see a new species of deer, for example, come up out of the ground before him, "pawing to get free," like Milton's lion, but his theory implied as much. And that theory, let it be noted, was not the theory of Lyell alone, but of nearly all his associates in the geologic world. There is perhaps no other fact that will bring home to one so vividly the advance in thought of our own generation as the recollection that so crude, so almost unthinkable a conception could have been the current doctrine of science less than half a century ago.

This theory of special creation, moreover, excluded the current doctrine of uniformitarianism as night excludes day, though most thinkers of the time did not seem to be aware of the incompatibility of the two ideas. It may be doubted whether even Lyell himself fully realized it. If he did, he saw no escape from the dilemma, for it seemed to him that the record in the rocks clearly disproved the alternative Lamarckian hypothesis. And almost with one accord the paleontologists of the time sustained the verdict. Owen, Agassiz, Falconer, Barrande, Pictet, Forbes, repudiated the idea as unqualifiedly as their great predecessor Cuvier had done in the earlier generation. Some of them did, indeed, come to believe that there is evidence of a progressive development of life in the successive ages, but no such graded series of fossils had been discovered as would give countenance to the idea that one species had ever been transformed into another. And to nearly every one this objection seemed insuperable.



Latest articles

Random articles

  • reason to believe her dead, and that it was because of
  • My fellow prisoner was Kantos Kan, a padwar (lieutenant)
  • with nature's weapons and the exhibition of animal ferocity
  • died there of hunger and thirst it would be better so than
  • resting the electric lamp upon one of the little ebony
  • they reached the dead body at my feet. Then slowly they
  • scale, they were able to wriggle through without sticking
  • were an open book for the undisguised loathing upon his
  • in an iron sluice gate. The Eurasian had passed it, but
  • defenseless women I turned my head that I might not see
  • and the charging chieftain pitched backward from his flying
  • the events which followed the defeat of the battleships.
  • of the Eurasian. She turned and faced him, threw up both
  • nor was there but the remotest possibility that they would
  • upon one beast, and Dejah Thoris behind me upon the other,
  • of the ruined edifices of the ancient city to prevent the
  • stars and waiting. He had lain thus and there many nights
  • quicker and more intelligent. It soon seemed that the encounter
  • me where first to seek, and advancing to the windows I
  • nights he had explored their quarters and their dungeons
  • reward that they would win from him if they carried his
  • In the others were wild calots, thoats, mad zitidars, green
  • him standing in the shadows of a mighty column, his fingers
  • the agony of his sorrow. Tomorrow the torture will commence;
  • freedom from doubt and questioning. Baynes had urged her
  • I thought of his love for me. Shortly after this Dejah
  • two revolvers upon them as a slight means of protection,
  • Presently it swung full upon us and—stopped. The tension
  • gate, but the apparatus was out of his reach, and he had
  • borne away; Dejah Thoris struggling to the last to free
  • There was not a mark of dignity or pride upon his bestial
  • neck of his erstwhile ruler he assumed the title of Jeddak
  • They were approaching the river, and there was a fog to-night!
  • the object of the fierce and jealous hatred of his old
  • on our nerves was near the breaking point, and I doubt
  • Zodanga, the capital of Helium's hereditary enemies among
  • He strove to peer about him, but the feeble ray of the
  • hall was thronged with chieftains, warriors and women,
  • they were traveling in the opposite direction. Quickly
  • Like the jed who had brought me, he was frightfully scarred,
  • possessed for him. So it came that his was a familiar figure
  • Fly, Sola! Dejah Thoris remains to die with the man she
  • I was from them I could read the scorn and disgust upon
  • making Dejah Thoris ride, much against her will. In this
  • Max gaining upon her, now, at every stride. There was a
  • We reached the city of Warhoon after some three days march
  • a furious pace in pursuit of the column. My wounds gave
  • to be the easy thing I had hoped, for the rear rooms bordering
  • reason we have seen so many parrots lately; the cheucau
  • of us and a trifle to the right we could distinguish the
  • tags